Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria Menu Prices With Calories [Updated 2025]

Salvatore’s is a famous pizza chain that uses the finest ingredients to craft delicious pizzas. The legend Sam often visited Cilino’s Pizza, owned by his friend Nino, to get an idea of different pizza flavors. In 1984, he attended the National Pizza Show, which helped expand the full pizza menu with new flavors.

Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria Restaurant

Today, that expanded menu still contains flavorful dishes, such as gourmet wings, flavorful salads, cheesy burgers, and, of course, everyone’s favorite desserts. Each menu item is crafted so that when you take a bite, you feel like the dishes are served directly from Italy only.

Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria’s Latest Menu With Prices

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Menu

Large Sub (Seeded)

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Shaved Steak Large Sub$15.54785NoNoNoNo
Turkey Breast Large Sub$14.34665NoNoNoNo
Chicken Finger Large Sub$15.54925NoNoNoNo
Mixed Meat Large Sub$13.89925NoNoNoNo
Grilled Chicken Large Sub$15.54745NoNoNoNo
Italian Assorted Large Sub$14.34725NoNoNoNo
Chicken Parmesan Large Sub$15.541302NoNoNoNo
BLT Large Sub$15.541407NoNoNoNo
Burger Large Sub$15.091145NoNoNoNo
Tuna Fish Large Sub$14.341161NoNoNoNo
Italian Sausage Large Sub$15.54965NoNoNoNo
Pizza Sub Large Sub$15.54780NoNoNoNo
Eggplant Parmesan Large Sub$15.541210NoNoNoNo
Chicken Cordon Bleu Large Sub$15.091210NoNoNoNo
Meatball Mama Large Sub$15.541375NoNoNoNo
Roast Beef Large Sub$14.34695NoNoNoNo
Baked Ham Large Sub$14.34605NoNoNoNo
Breaded Chicken Large Sub$15.091310NoNoNoNo
Genoa Salami Large Sub$14.34965NoNoNoNo
Assorted Cheese Large Sub$14.34785NoNoNoNo
Capicola Large Sub$14.34695NoNoNoNo
Veggie Large Sub$14.34636NoYesNoNo

Medium Sub (Seeded)

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Shaved Steak Large Sub$13.14535NoNoNoNo
Turkey Breast Large Sub$11.94455NoNoNoNo
Meatball Mama Medium Sub$13.14875NoNoNoNo
Italian Assorted Medium Sub$11.94515NoNoNoNo
Tuna Fish Medium Sub$11.94786NoNoNoNo
Burger Medium Sub$12.69830NoNoNoNo
Chicken Finger Medium Sub$13.14665NoNoNoNo
Chicken Parmesan Medium Sub$12.69929NoNoNoNo
Baked Ham Medium Sub$11.94455NoNoNoNo
Veggie Medium Sub$11.94436NoYesNoNo
Italian Sausage Medium Sub$13.14655NoNoNoNo
Pizza Sub Medium Sub$13.14520NoNoNoNo
BLT Medium Sub$13.14944NoNoNoNo
Grilled Chicken Medium Sub$13.14530NoNoNoNo
Mixed Meat Medium Sub$11.49675NoNoNoNo
Eggplant Parmesan Medium Sub$13.14860NoNoNoNo
Roast Beef Medium Sub$11.94475NoNoNoNo
Genoa Salami Medium Sub$11.94655NoNoNoNo
Assorted Cheese Medium Sub$11.94560NoNoNoNo
Capicola Medium Sub$11.94475NoNoNoNo

Appetizers

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Mozzarella Sticks$10.26450NoNoNoNo
Fresh Cut Fries$8.101424NoNoNoNo
Pizza Fingers$6.99700NoNoNoNo
Fried Mushrooms$9.06500NoNoNoNo
Garlic Bread With Mozzarella $10.26880NoNoNoNo
Loaded Fries$17.941779NoNoNoNo
Onion Rings$8.10750NoNoNoNo
Sausage Slingers$15.061050NoNoNoNo
Pizza Fries$11.941420NoNoNoNo
Home Fries$8.101477NoNoNoNo

Superslice

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Superslice Combo$11.94By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Superslice with Mozzarella & Pepperoni (1 Sl)$6.69768NoNoNoNo
Personal Pizza$8.45By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Superslice with Mozzarella(1 Sl)$7.14752NoNoNoNo

Pizzas & Calzones

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Large Pizza$23.95160NoNoNoNo
Medium Pizza$20.34170NoNoNoNo
Sheet Pizza$33.55160NoNoNoNo
Giant Calzone$20.341371NoNoNoNo
Thin Thin Crust(12″)$11.94480NoNoNoNo
Ny Style(19″)$25.15350NoNoNoNo

Specialty Pizza

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Chicken Charlie With Country Sweet$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Salvatore’s Supreme Pizza$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Breakfast Pizza With Meat$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
The Salvatore Pizza$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
The Meathead Pizza$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Ranch$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Chicken Charlie With Mild Sauce$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Linda Da’ Veggie Pizza$15.55By add-onsNoYesNoNo
Uncle Rico’s BBQ Chicken Pizza$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Vegan With Vegan Cheese$13.09By add-onsYesNoNoNo
The Taco Pizza Since 1978$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Alfredo, Not My Brother Pizza$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Steak Boomba With Country Sweet Sauce$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Fish Fry$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Mama Toni’s Plate Pizza$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Breakfast Pizza With Veggies$15.55By add-onsNoYesNoNo
Vegan No Vegan Cheese$0.75By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Steak Boomba$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Soccer Sam’s Low Fat Pizza$15.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo

Thin Thin Twins

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Thin Thin Twins$17.95480-960NoNoNoNo

Pizza Bowls

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Build Your Own Bowl$10.75By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Specialty Pizza Bowl$10.75By add-onsNoNoNoNo

Roll Sub (Seedless)

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Shaved Steak Roll$10.29400NoNoNoNo
Turkey Breast Roll$9.09360NoNoNoNo
Tuna Fish Roll$9.09525NoNoNoNo
Chicken Finger Roll$10.29520NoNoNoNo
Baked Ham Roll$9.09360NoNoNoNo
Chicken Parmesan Roll$10.29671NoNoNoNo
Italian Sausage Roll$10.29460NoNoNoNo
Mixed Meat Roll$9.09820NoNoNoNo
BLT Roll$10.29588NoNoNoNo
Meatball Mama Roll$10.29650NoNoNoNo
Italian Assorted Roll$9.09420NoNoNoNo
Roasted Beef Roll$9.09370NoNoNoNo
Chicken Cordeu Bleu Roll$9.09800NoNoNoNo
Veggie Roll$9.09350NoYesNoNo
Genoa Salami Roll$9.09480NoNoNoNo
Capicola Roll$9.09370NoNoNoNo
Assorted Cheese Roll$9.09450NoNoNoNo
Pizza Sub Roll$10.29375NoNoNoNo
Eggplant Parmesan Roll$10.29625NoNoNoNo
Grilled Chicken Roll$10.29430NoNoNoNo

Wraps

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Chicken Finger Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Grilled Chicken Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Shaved Steak Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Chicken Cordon Bleu Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Turkey Breast Wrap$11.29By add-onsNoNoNoNo
BLT Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Tuna Fish Wrap$11.49By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Mixed Meat Wrap$11.49By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Fried Chicken Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Italian Assorted Wrap$11.49By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Roast Beef Wrap$11.49By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Baked Ham Wrap$11.49By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Veggie Wrap$11.49By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Eggplant Parmesan Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Burger Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Genoa Salami Wrap$11.49By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Capicola Wrap$11.49By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Assorted Cheese Wrap$11.49By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Meatball Mama Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Sausage Parmesan Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Pizza Sub Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Chicken Parmesan Wrap$12.69By add-onsNoNoNoNo

Specialty Wraps

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Buffalo Chicken Wrap$13.14520NoNoNoNo
Chicken Caesar Wrap$13.14770NoNoNoNo
Cajun Chicken Wrap$13.14880NoNoNoNo

Original Wings

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Original Wings$11.35198NoNoNoNo

Sweet Country Breaded Wings

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Breaded Wings$13.75287NoNoNoNo
Breaded Wings Mac Snack Pack (5 pcs)$17.95By add-onsNoNoNoNo

Chicken Fingers & Sandwiches

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Chicken Fingers$13.14By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Chicken Sandwich$16.741308-1072NoNoNoNo
Chicken Cordon Bleu Sandwich$17.941212NoNoNoNo

Pasta Dinners

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Side Dish$7.15By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Stuffed Shells$19.141070NoNoNoNo
Breaded Chicken Parmesan$20.351290NoNoNoNo
Pasta With Meatballs$19.141028NoNoNoNo
Eggplant Parmesan$20.341393NoNoNoNo
Baked Pasta With Mozzarella Sauce$17.94918NoNoNoNo
Meatball Mania (2 Pcs)$7.14By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Meatball Mania (4 Pcs)$11.94By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Grilled Chicken Parmesan$22.74818NoNoNoNo
Haddock Parmesan$22.741608NoNoNoNo

Burgers, Plates & Hots

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Cheeseburger Plate$20.341030NoNoNoNo
Hot Dog$5.95335NoNoNoNo
Salvatore’s Burger$10.75570NoNoNoNo
Hamburger Plate (1/2)$14.34560NoNoNoNo
Cheeseburger Plate (1/2)$14.34630NoNoNoNo
Double Cheese Burger$13.891400NoNoNoNo
Cheeseburger$11.94640NoNoNoNo
Italian Burger$11.94670-680NoNoNoNo
Cheeseburger (1 Pc), Hot Dog Plate (1 Pc)$19.15By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Hamburger (1 Pc), Italian Sausage Plate (1 Pc)$19.15By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Bleu Cheese Burger$11.94710NoNoNoNo
Italian Sausage Plate$20.34870NoNoNoNo
Italian Sausage Plate(1/2)$14.34550NoNoNoNo
BBQ Burger$11.94630NoNoNoNo
Hamburger Plate$20.34890NoNoNoNo
Double Burger$13.62900NoNoNoNo
Grilled Chicken Plate$20.34490NoNoNoNo
Cheeseburger (1 Pc), Italian Sausage Plate (1 Pc)$19.15By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Hotdog Plate$20.34670NoNoNoNo
Salvie Burger$11.94840NoNoNoNo
Swiss Burger$11.94650NoNoNoNo
Steak Plate$20.34530NoNoNoNo
Chicken Fingers Plate$20.34670NoNoNoNo
Veggie Plate$20.34380NoYesNoNo
Hamburger (1 Pc), Hot Dog Plate (1 Pc)$19.15By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Italian Sausage (1 Pc), Hot Dog Plate (1 Pc)$19.15By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Hot Dog Plate (1/2)$14.34450NoNoNoNo
Steak Plate (1/2)$14.34380NoNoNoNo
Grilled Chicken Plate (1/2)$14.34360NoNoNoNo
Chicken Fingers Plate (1/2)$14.34450NoNoNoNo
Veggie Plate (1/2)$14.34305NoYesNoNo

Soups & Salads

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Caesar Salad$14.34287NoNoNoNo
Tossed Salad$10.74100NoNoNoNo
Side Salad$7.1460NoNoNoNo
Buffalo Chicken Salad$15.54425NoNoNoNo
Garlic Bread$9.09880NoNoNoNo
Its Greek To Me$14.34280NoNoNoNo
Antipasto Salad$14.34353NoNoNoNo
Grilled Chicken Salad$15.54275NoNoNoNo
Cajun Chicken Salad$15.54285NoNoNoNo
Tuna Topped Salad$14.34325NoNoNoNo
Loaf Of Famous Large Sub Bread$2.45By add-onsNoNoNoNo

Fish Frys & Shrimp Dinners

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Battered Fish Fry-includes 2 Sides$19.152017NoNoNoNo
Big Bertha’s Giant Fish Sandwich$16.751245NoNoNoNo
Salvatore’s Style Breaded Shrimp Dinner (10 Pc)$20.352135-2835NoNoNoNo
Breaded Shrimp Dinner (10 pcs)$19.151574NoNoNoNo

Desserts

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Fresh Baked Cookie$2.10By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Cannoli (2Pkt)$7.86460NoNoNoNo
Carrot Cake$7.86540NoNoNoNo
Cookies (4Pkt)$7.86By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Peanut Butter Pie$7.86640NoNoNoNo
Raspberry Cheesecake$7.86362NoNoNoNo
Cannoli (1 pc)$3.95230NoNoNoNo
Cheesecake$7.86560NoNoNoNo

Sides & Sauces

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Salvatore’s Blue Cheese (2oz) (Cup)$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Ken’s Ranch Dressing (2 oz) (Pouch)$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Sweet Country Style (2oz) (Cup)$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Garlic Bread$9.09By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Salvatore’s Pizza Sauce (4oz) (Cup)$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Salvatore’s Pizza Sauce (4oz)$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Regular Lays Chips$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Hot Wing Sauce$1.85By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Ken’s Tartar Sauce (2 oz) (Pouch)$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Mild Wing Sauce$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Coleslaw$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Sour Cream (1oz) (Cup)$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Side Order-Breaded Chicken$4.85By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Nacho Doritos Chips$1.85By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Ken’s BBQ Sauce (2oz) (Cup)$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Ken’s Caesar Dressing$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Salvie Plate Hot Sauce (2oz) (Cup)$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Ken’s Honey Mustard Sauce$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Hard Roll$0.75By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Large Bread$2.45By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Side Order-Tuna Fish$1.19By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Zesty Italian$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Cooler Ranch Doritos Chips$1.85By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Ken’s 1000 Island Dressing$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Medium Bread$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Ken’s French Dressing$1.25By add-onsNoNoNoNo

Drinks

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Drinks (2lts)$4.79By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Drink (Bottle)(20 oz)$3.59By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Iced Tea Drinks$3.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Juices $3.54By add-onsNoNoNoNo
Gatorade$3.55By add-onsNoNoNoNo

Water

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten-FreeKeto
Aquafina$3.59NilYesYesYesYes
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Menu Item
popular items icon

Popular Items On The Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria Menu

What Are People Asking About Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria?

Salvatores Old Fashioned Pizzeria Food

Current Deals Running At Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria

1. $10 Deals

For only $10, you get a special value pack; every day, the pack is different. So, the pack for different days is as follows:

i. Monday: Medium size 12″ Pizza with plenty of Mozzarella and extra toppings. 

ii. Tuesday: Baked Pasta with Mozzarella with a Giant Loaf of Garlic Bread.

iii. Wednesday: Giant Calzone with lots of mozzarellas and 2 Toppings. 

iv. Thursday: Large Cold Sub & 20 oz Pepsi Product. If you swap the cold sub for a hot sub, you’ll need to pay $2 extra. 

v. Friday: 10 Pc Mozz Sticks with a side of tomato sauce. 

vi. Saturday: Thin Thin Pizza Mozzarella & 1 topping & 20 oz Pepsi product. 

vii. Sunday: 10 pc boneless wings with blue cheese & choice of sauce. 

viii. Everyday Special (available all days of the week): 20 oz slice, chips, or cookie. 

Please note that the available menu details under $10 are specific to New York locations only. The menu details for other locations vary. Hence, you must check the details with the nearest branch for other locations. 

2. Coupons Special

i. For $17, you can get a large pizza with lots of mozzarella. The coupon code is PR271.

ii. For $34, you can get a large 16″ pizza with lots of mozzarella and 10 pc boneless wings. Coupon code: PR272.

Important Note

  • For delivery and extra toppings, extra charges are applied. 
  • No coupon can be used to collaborate with other coupons. 
  • All three coupons will expire on 31st Dec 2024. 
  • Please note you can select between jumbo and boneless wings. 

3. Pizza Perks

You can join Pizza Perks’ loyalty program at Salvatore’s to earn points on your purchases. Later, you can redeem these points for free lunch or dinner at participating restaurants. 

Note: Salvatore’s is celebrating its 45th anniversary, and to honor this, it is giving all its club members 45 points. 

4. Birthday Special 

All Pizza Perks members are eligible to get a free medium-sized Birthday Pizza with one topping. Please note that no coupons are required to redeem this gift. To get your birthday reward, follow the below steps. 

i. When completing the Pizza Perk form, make sure that you have filled out the birthday details properly. 

ii. The birthday promo becomes active on your birthday date, and you have one week to take advantage of it. 

iii. Ensure you order using the mobile number you used to join the club. 

iv. If you order a free birthday pizza on the official site, ensure that you use the Pizza Perk account.

How We’ve Verified This Data?

Purple Icon

Commitment To Quality

Green icons

Cross-Verify

Yello Icon

Lastly If

Other Restaurants’ Menu That We’ve Covered

Conclusion

In conclusion, I would like to say that the Hamburger Stand is the best food spot to enjoy delish burgers and other fast-food meals. Additionally, the customization option makes this place a go-to place for flavorful burger options.

However, the unavailability of deals is a little heartbreaking. Still, you can visit as prices are reasonable.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *